← Back to Evaluating AI Output

Tomorrow Ready · Evaluating AI Output

Evaluate Before You Draft: The Evaluation Gate for English Years 11 to 13

Subject adaptation · Years 11 to 13 · English / Literacy · Field-Based STEM · Tony Jones

The student who accepts the first interpretive position they generate has not yet evaluated. They have accepted. The Evaluation Gate makes that difference visible before the essay is written, not after it is submitted.

Generate
Candidate approaches
Identify
Name the criterion
Compare
Against the criterion
Justify
In writing, before drafting

The Strategy

The Evaluation Gate requires students to evaluate before they commit. Two or three candidate approaches, one named criterion, one comparison, one written justification: this sequence makes the selection decision visible and assessable before any drafting begins.

  1. Before drafting begins, students receive or produce two to three candidate approaches: thesis positions, interpretive angles, or structural plans for the writing task.
  2. Students name one criterion relevant to the task: textual evidence, audience fit, argumentative coherence, or alignment with the achievement standard descriptor.
  3. Students locate evidence for each candidate approach against the named criterion and annotate the comparison.
  4. Students write a one to two sentence justification for their chosen approach and submit it to the teacher before any drafting begins.

In Practice

Year 11

Teacher provides the two or three candidate approaches. Students select the criterion from a short teacher-provided list. Justification is written in class before the drafting session begins.

Years 12 to 13

Students generate their own candidate approaches and name their own criterion. The justification is assessed as a component of the achievement standard submission. At Merit and Excellence, the justification names a reason specific to this text and this task.

Implementation

Decision Checkpoint

If two students submit identical justifications, return both with one question: "What is the specific reason this approach works for your reading of this text?" The justification must be tied to the local text, not to a general essay-writing principle.

Teacher Judgement Note

The Evaluation Gate justification is process evidence; keep it brief enough that students are not spending disproportionate time on the gate relative to the essay itself.

Related Frameworks

Evidence Lock · Position First Protocol · Friction Framing

Tony Jones · Founder, Field-Based STEM · Tomorrow Ready Resources · Free to use and share