← Evaluating AI Output

Tomorrow Ready · Evaluating AI Output

Name Your Weakest Assumption First — Social Sciences Years 4–6

Subject adaptation  ·  Years 4–6  ·  Social Sciences  ·  Field-Based STEM  ·  Tony Jones

AI tools that feel collaborative will affirm the position a student already holds. Friction Framing surfaces the weakest assumption before any tool opens, so the challenge belongs to the task design rather than to the teacher.

Phase 1
Write Your Position
Phase 2
Name the Weakness
Phase 3
Make a Commitment
Phase 4
Collect the Artefact

The Strategy

Before any research or tool use begins, students write their current position, name the part they are least certain of, and commit in writing to either revise or hold firm with a specific reason.

  1. Before any source work opens, students write their current position on the inquiry question in one to two sentences.
  2. Students name the part of that position they are least certain of: the weakest assumption.
  3. Students make a written commitment: accept the challenge and state how they will revise, or reject it with one specific reason for holding firm.
  4. The original position, the identified weakness, and the commitment are collected as a single artefact alongside the finished inquiry.

The friction step creates a record of independent reasoning that exists before any tool is opened and cannot be reconstructed after the fact.

In Practice

Years 4–5 — Local land use inquiry

Students write their initial prediction about why land in their area is used as it is. Most assume the land has always served its current purpose. The friction step asks why that might not be true. The commitment produces a specific revision or a stated reason to hold firm, before a single source is opened.

Year 6 — Community decision-making

Students name their initial position on whether a local issue was handled fairly. The friction step surfaces assumptions about who has authority to decide. The commitment creates a record of the student's reasoning before any research shapes it.

Implementation Notes

Decision checkpoint

The friction step is not a test. Frame it as: "What part of your idea are you least sure about?" Students who struggle to name a weakness often have the most to gain from the prompt.

Teacher judgement note

Where a student's position connects to whanau or community identity, receive the friction step as an invitation to strengthen reasoning, not as a challenge to personal knowledge.

Related frameworks

Position First Protocol  ·  Context Triage (Social Sciences Years 1–3)  ·  What AI Won't Tell You You're Wrong

Tony Jones  ·  Founder, Field-Based STEM Tomorrow Ready Resources  ·  Free to use and share