← Back to Traceable Decisions

Tomorrow Ready · Traceable Decisions

Close the Tools, Then Account: Reconstruction Check, Health and PE Years 9 to 10

Subject adaptation · Years 9 to 10 · Health and Physical Education · Field-Based STEM · Tony Jones

A polished submission is evidence of production. What a student can reconstruct from memory, without access to their work, is evidence of understanding. The Reconstruction Check makes that distinction visible before the grade is assigned.

Draft
Complete the task
Close
All tools shut
Reconstruct
From memory
Collect
Diagnostic artefact

The Strategy

The Reconstruction Check separates fluent production from genuine understanding. After any drafting phase, students account for their key decisions from memory. What they can reconstruct belongs to them. The reconstruction is a diagnostic artefact, not a repeat of the task.

  1. Students complete their health or PE task using any permitted resources, tools, and collaboration.
  2. At a designated moment before submission, students close all devices, notes, and drafts. No reopening until the reconstruction is complete.
  3. Students write responses to three prompts from memory: one decision they made, one piece of evidence they used, and one thing they would change.
  4. The teacher collects reconstruction responses before students reopen their work. The reconstruction is assessed alongside the main task.

In Practice

Year 9

Three reconstruction prompts are provided on a printed slip. Students write two to three sentences per prompt. Teacher uses responses to identify which students need a brief follow-up conversation before marking begins.

Year 10

Students write reconstruction responses without a prompt slip. The reconstruction is assessed as a graded component of the submission alongside the main piece of work, not as a pass or fail gate.

Implementation

Decision Checkpoint

If a student's reconstruction does not match the content of their submitted work in a significant way, schedule a two-minute conversation before assigning a grade. The mismatch is diagnostic, not automatically a penalty.

Teacher Judgement Note

Some students reconstruct less fluently than their written work suggests, not because they are dishonest but because working memory retrieval under time pressure is genuinely harder for some learners. Use a follow-up conversation before drawing conclusions about ownership.

Related Frameworks

Trace Map · Decision Vignette · Evidence Overlay

Tony Jones · Founder, Field-Based STEM · Tomorrow Ready Resources · Free to use and share